Been meaning to post this, it’s Bill’s response to my review of his e-book, How to Beat NLHE 6-Max Cash Games:
Thanks for reviewing the book.
I won’t comment on everything — you have some valid points although I do feel a beginner can use this book. It’s a little steep for a true beginner but with some work I think anyone can get it (my Mom’s never played or read about poker but is now giving the micro’s a go after reading my book :P)
My target audience was from beginners to 200 NL players FWIW. Things like the 600NL video to show what a game like that plays like.
Agreed the affiliate shilling is lame and will be removed in the next edition.
As for things like the games changing, I plan to update the book every 6 months or so to keep it fresh and up to date — such as 3-bet %, which is available on Hold ‘Em Manager and will be on PT3, will be very important stats to use in upcoming games.
I feel the book has more value than you do, although that’s up to interpretations about my writing. From my experience with poker books, I’ve felt I’ve wrote concepts more clearly and plainly in a conversational tone so someone can really understand it and apply it.
Also, as for “you need more experience..” stuff. I can see it being considered a “cop out” though it’s what I really feel. I think some things just can’t be explained in a book.. I would need to be 1 on 1 with someone, know exactly how they play, etc etc before I could really give them advice on some deeper subjects.
“deeper subjects” please …